My 2000 Forester, same engine has had no problems in 99,000 miles. So
much depends on how the maintenance was kept up.
I thought the Foresters had the 2.2 back then?
As for the OP & the '01 OBW, I sold mine in March, with 39k. Here's
my thoughts related to my ONE example:
Pros:
- Best snow vehicle, ever! I've had plenty of 4x4's and they didn't
compare. I can't underline this praise enough.
- Consistent 22-23 MPG, with a four bike roof rack or towing a small
~1000 pound trailer and 75 MPH highway cruise speeds. Without the
rack, about 24-25 was the norm for me. Considering the size and
weight of the car, I was happy with the mileage.
- Comfy for a large range of driver and passenger sizes
- The heated seats, mirrors, and wipers were awesome and well worth
the money.
- Excellent use of interior space
- I was happy with the interior style, layout, materials, etc... for
the entire time I owned it. The dark grey cloth hid the grunge I left
from mountain biking, crawling under my airplane, home improvements,
etc... very well.
- I liked the stereo, with 6 disc changer & sub (after tweaking!)
- Plenty of power from the 4 banger, cruise control worked great
- Easy and relatively fun to drive car, but it's no WRX.
- I could fit 10'+ moldings, hardwood, and PVC pipe inside (one end on
the dash), with the rear gate shut.
- Subaru's online service documentation is reasonably priced,
accurate, and very usable.
Cons
- The clutch sucked, and my local dealership's support was even worse.
- The clutch slipped from 7k on...
- The clutch stunk (like burning lining)
- The clutch was worrisome...
- Clutch issues were documented on "Car Talk" radio show, and several
written columns, Subaru still refused to own up. Get it yet? <G>
- ABS kicked in way early for my taste
- The brakes are barely up to the task, especially when towing well
within the published limits. Needed new front pads, that I installed
myself, at 29k.
- The headlights stunk
- Build quality of my Indiana-built 2001 example was average. Much
better than my Jeeps & company provided Chevy, about the same as my
Nissans and Mazdas, but well behind my Toyotas. This comment is based
entirely on vehicles I've actually owned.
- Drivers door rattled when shut, especially with the window down.
This was never resolved. It really made the car sound cheesily made.
- I never really got into the exterior styling.
As far as the clutch and brakes go, it 'ain't me! I typically get
100,000+ on clutches and 45k+ on brakes. The only reason I think this
problem isn't more apparent is that OBW's are relatively rare with
manual transmissions.
The performance and drivability of the 4 cylinder engine is far better
with the stick over the automatic in the '00-'02 models. I haven't
driven anything later, so I can't comment.